Captain D's doesn't have an official secret menu, but regulars have figured out plenty of ways to get more for their money and customize their orders. Here are the hacks that actually work.
Build Your Own Platter
Instead of a fixed combo, ask to mix a piece of fish with a few butterfly shrimp and a side or two. You can effectively design a custom sampler — try our platter builder to plan it first.
The Family-Meal-for-Two Hack
If two people are very hungry, a family meal can actually be cheaper per ounce than two separate combos, and you'll have leftovers. Split a 10-piece fish family meal and you're eating well for under $9 a head.
Free(ish) Hush Puppies
Most fish and shrimp meals already include hush puppies — don't pay to add them as a separate side. Same goes for confirming which dipping sauce comes standard before buying extra.
Use the Deals Stack
Sign up for the email club and check the app for $4.99 meal deals and senior specials (60+). Stacking a deal with a shared family side is the cheapest way to feed a small group.
Grilled Swap for Macros
Order any grilled fish "no rice, extra broccoli" for a high-protein, low-carb plate that isn't on the standard menu but is easy for the kitchen to do.
Frequently Asked Questions
Not officially, but you can build custom platters, swap sides, and stack deals to create combinations that aren't on the standard board.
Use app deals and senior specials, split a family meal, and stick to add-on-priced single items like a 1-piece fish or hush puppies.
Yes — swap sides, hold sauces, ask for grilled with extra veggies, or mix proteins on a plate. The kitchen is generally flexible.